how to make edible chalk

Thanks for sharing! You can also use the quick buy feature to add product to your shopping cart quickly. Insert the bag into the top of one of the straws and gently squeeze until the straw fills with candy coating. Thanks for sharing! Pour the yogurt in each container. 3. deep fry the pieces ( see that the pieces turn in golden brown colour) 4. take the sugar solution in the same vessel in which they are deep fried. If the candy won’t come out, you may need to freeze it for a minute or two longer.Break the candy chalk into pieces. SAWN edible Chalk chunks (lump) natural for eating (food), 450 g 3.4 out of 5 stars 18. Thank you for a great idea! The Edible Clay Ural 200gr. Allow to come to room temperature before using on chocolate chalkboard. Step 1. Have fun creating this tasty craft with your kids! Heat on high for 10 seconds. If you want to add some special touches to your boards, you can add a frame, an apple, or any other decoration using modeling chocolate. I used three straws and had more than enough chalk for my three chalkboards. Can I buy it from you. Sign up for our newsletter and get our cookbook! ». The quantities in this recipe are endlessly flexible. Squeeze candy into each of the straws filling completely. May 21, 2017 - Cake blog with edible artwork, cakes and cupcakes, and tutorials on pinterest. You are a genius. That's a great idea! Pica is the desire to eat non-foodstuffs, or materials that aren’t meant for human consumption. !… Thanks for sharing!! These are incredible…just unbelievably creative. Making this edible finger paint is oh-so-simple! Choose the weight. This sidewalk chalk recipe only takes 3 ingredients and a mold and you are all set to go to create your own summer fun! Snip the corner of the piping bag and squeeze the mixture into the cardboard tube, tapping to get the plaster mixture to settle. Recipe: Edible Chalkboard Cake and Candy Chalk. Making non-toxic sidewalk chalk is an easy craft project that you can do with all ages of children at home. I was wondering what to get the teachers this year. Add to Cart . Color some modeling chocolate brown to create the apple stems and some green for the leaves. Once you’ve completed your writing, sprinkle some powdered sugar over the candy bar.Use the pastry brush to brush the powdered sugar across the candy bar. 5. add the pieces into the solution. Cut into 1/2″-1″ thick strips. This small amount of candy will burn very easily, so be sure to melt slowly. Total genius!!! May 21, 2017 - Cake blog with edible artwork, cakes and cupcakes, and tutorials on pinterest. Freeze candy to set (refrigerate pure chocolate bars) then un-mold the bars and let them come up to room temperature before proceeding.Note: The candy mold that I used needed 5.75 ounces to fill, so I used just over a pound of chocolate to make my three bars. Once your cookie chalkboards are completed, you can write on them with the candy chalk. Haley Pierson-Cox from Red-Handled Scissors is a maker of crafts, a lover of cats, an avid swearing enthusiast, a cross-stitch book author, and a general purveyor of quirk. A lot of people will argue that chalk is pica and ingesting is harmful to your health.You may have to check your iron levels to make sure this is not the case. Now to transform your candy bar into a chalkboard, you need to rough up the surface of the candy bar. I love everything you are doing here. Since we have a 10 year old, we have passed everything but the chalk to the toddlers in my brother’s family, and we just tried the chalk. Once the candy is hardened, you simply push the candy chalk out of the straw, using a wooden skewer or toothpick, and break it into pieces. The Spruce Eats uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. The chalkboards will surely be a big hit just as they are. Buy Edible chalk, Natural Chalk, "SAWN Chalk Belgorodskiy" 200gr. Press a fondant plaque on top, and repeat with remaining cookies. Learn how your comment data is processed. optional decorations: modeling chocolate, disposable pastry bag or a zip top bag How to make Edible Paint for babies. These cookies and chocolate chalk are fun to draw on and eat. If you buy bars, make sure they are at least 5″ long, so you have plenty of room to write your message.If you make or buy break apart bars (bars that are scored on one side to make it easier to break apart the candy bar) make sure the bars are pretty thick. This looks amazing! 2. : Chalk Lines - Amazon.com FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases Use the candy chalk to write a special message on your candy bars. Thank you for sharing. To Make the Candy Chalk Sticks Place the candy coating in a microwave-safe bowl and microwave in 30-second increments, stirring after every 30 seconds, until melted and smooth. We love the toddler edible art supplies from Wee Can Too,that are completely safe if ingested, as they are made from organic fruit and vegetable powders. Wish my kids were still in school!!!!!!! Preheat oven to 350°F. Refrigerate the straws for at least 20 minutes, until chilled thoroughly. May 20, 2011 This post may contain affiliate links. Snip the straws into thirds so that you have 12 smaller straws the size of chalk sticks. Materials: Small container ( $2 zip-lock containers) Food Coloring (McCormick brand is a good one) Heavy Stock Paper (I use mixed media paper) Instructions to prepare the paint. By using The Spruce Eats, you accept our, 13 Best Popcorn Recipes for Movie Night In, 26 Winter Dishes and Holiday Treats for Kids, Your Step-By-Step Guide on Decorating Christmas Cookies. I'm a teacher and would LOVE to get such a thoughtful gift! If you are looking for more fun Back to School or Teacher Appreciation Gift ideas be sure to check out all these other amazing food craft and recipe ideas on my School & Teacher Treats Page. 3. Review Your Cart When you write on them with the white chocolate chalk, you’ll need to use a bit of pressure and you don’t want to break your bars. You will find all you need to know about making and coloring modeling chocolate to use as decorations for your chalkboards. Playing with your food is as fun as eating it. Create an EdibleChalk.com Account or Login. Roll out the black fondant until it is very thin, 1/8-inch thick or less. If you aren’t going to add decorations, squeeze the remaining candy onto a piece of parchment paper and freeze it for 5 minutes then you can use it for another project.Freeze your candy filled straws for 5-10 minutes. The idea for edible candy chalk was inspired by Rosie Alyea's book The Sweetapolita Bakebook. £9.55. Place one strip on each of the four sides of your chalkboard, overlapping the strips at the corners. We've found that "bright white" coating produces the best results, but you can experiment with other colors as well. Mix together flour, baking soda, salt, nutmeg, and baking powder together in a large bowl. You will need to make your own edible chalk, by pouring melted white confectionery coating/candy melts (or tempered white chocolate) into a drinking straw. Stir. Looking to make the best desserts ever? One container per color •Drop 4 … Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Pour a few inches of sugar in a glass. OMG!!! Place the candy coating in a microwave-safe bowl and microwave in 30-second increments, stirring after every 30 seconds, until melted and smooth. Use a dowel or a skewer to push the candy chalk sticks out of the straws. Allow the sidewalk chalk to dry overnight. Pinch off about a teaspoonful and roll into a ball. To remove the candy from the straw, push a wooden skewer or toothpick into the straw and push the candy up and out of the straw. Set your timer. Am now a new follower:) I'm currently looking for guest posters for tasty treat projects this summer – would love to have you share an idea! Select your products. Once the candy is hardened, you simply push the candy chalk out of the straw, using a … You don’t want to forget them in the freezer as the candy will become sticky if left in the freezer too long and wont come out of the straw. Nov 22, 2013 - I've got five months to go before my next birthday, but I've already decided on the cake thanks to this awesome tutorial for making an edible chalkboard cake and candy chalk to go with it! Experiment with different molds and colors to create … You can tape off suggestions for nice clean lines and geometric shapes similar to our tape resist rainbow art here. Pour 1/4 cup of white confectionery coating into a small microwave safe bowl. Squeeze remaining candy back into the bowl – if you plan to add any decorations to your chalkboards you will need it to attach the pieces of modeling chocolate. 3.4 out of 5 stars 237. So glad I did. I am looking for white edible ink. Tie on some ribbon and you have a fun teacher’s gift. I have a hobby business. I made my own large chocolate bars, but you can just buy your favorite chocolate bars if you prefer. These chocolate chalkboards can be personalized for any occasion and will make great gifts for teachers, students, and faculty members. £23.95. The first two methods will require Wilton Candy Melts in bright white color. Remove the excess modeling chocolate then gently press the two angled strips together. Use big fat milkshake straws vs normal thin straws. Here are a few different variations you might find worth trying. I hate having to run to the store in the middle of a project. A bit of powdered sugar can be sprinkled over the chocolate chalkboard and brushed off using a pastry brush to make your chalkboard look as though it has been used by a classroom of students. Once your chalkboards and chalk sticks are made, give them a try—the chalk does actually write on the chalkboard. How cute is that!!! So, as the school year was coming to an end, my mom and I would create handmade crafts or bake up some sweet treats to give to my teachers to thank them for being so special.If you and your kids are looking for a project to do together that would make a great teacher’s gift, why not try making these really cute chalkboards made from chocolate? If you want a more elaborate chalkboard you can use modeling chocolate to add decorations: Dust your work surface with some powdered sugar. Then you use the chalk to write a special message on the chocolate chalkboard. Wrap them in clear cellophane bags or using clear cellophane sheets. Your chalkboard now looks like it has had a lot of school lessons written and wiped away over the years. Unbelievable. Thanks for the great idea! Next, mix equal parts cornstarch and water in a bowl, and add food coloring if you want to make colored chalk. ; Or make an outdoor activity course along your sidewalk for everyone to join in…; Write a special note for the delivery driver or garbage person! Take a pastry brush or a paper towel and rub the bar to take away the shine of the bar. I can't wait to try it with the kids…. Stir vigorously. This simple treat is so much fun to make and such an easy project. Insert drinking straws into the sugar. Heat for 10 more seconds. Transfer the melted coating to a disposable piping bag, or a large plastic zip-top bag. How amazing is this! I recommend you use bars at least this big to make your chalkboards. Cake decorating tutorials, step by step how to figurines, fondant. Flatten and shape it into an apple shape. Apr 27, 2015 - Learn how to make edible chalk for a chalkboard design for cookies, cupcakes and cakes in my new tutorial video. I'm a teacher and I would've never thought of making something like this. Alexis Salcedo Step 2 1. make a dough with maida, a pinch of salt and water as required. It is so exciting to see so many nice comments about my chocolate chalkboards. A professional pastry chef, cookbook author, and writer, Elizabeth LaBau has published more than 600 articles on baking and candy making. As found in nature, chalk has been used for drawing since prehistoric times, when, according to archaeologists, it helped to create some of the earliest cave drawings. To make homemade chalk using cornstarch, line a toilet paper roll with a piece of wax paper, making sure the waxed side is exposed. Re-roll and cut more as necessary, until you have one fondant plaque for each cookie. (I used a 6-1/2″ by 4-1/2″ rectangle mold). Just a thought. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. ~~ Robyne. Your email address will not be published. Learn how to make this Edible Candy Chalk with Cookie Chalkboards. Dust your work surface with cocoa powder. This is REALLY GREAT!!! Manufactured Chalk are made commercially for schools or for Gym Use and are not edible. Haley Pierson-Cox. Wow wow wow thanks a bunch for this post what a great end of the year post for a lucky teacher. Templates – Printable Templates for Halloween Crafts and Recipes, How to Store and Work with Modeling Chocolate, Use Colored Candy Melts to Make Candy Clay, How To Color White Chocolate and Candy Melts and Paint Candy Molds, « Cheese Ball Wedding Cakes – Elegant Appetizer, Inside Out Chocolate Caramel Apples make great teacher’s gifts. ... Sidewalk Chalk Paint: On nicer days, the whole family will love using this chalk paint outdoors! glass filled with a few inches of sugar BELGOROD SAWN edible Chalk chunks (lump) natural for eating (food), 4 oz (110 g) 3.5 out of 5 stars 13. optional: candy bar candy molds (I used a 6-1/2″ by 4-1/2″ rectangle mold), Candy Bars (You can buy them or make them.). Use the same cookie cutter you used for the cookies to cut shapes out of the fondant. Wow. To make an apple, color some white modeling chocolate with red candy coloring. Snip a small hole in the corner of the bag or the bottom of the piping bag. Well, I did, anyway. Calling chalk edible - we are referring to a purified natural chalk with no additives or chemicals, which is suitable for food, as opposed to clerical or industrial precipitated chalk. Manufactured Chalk. Plus an extra chocolate bar will never go to waste. I hope you enjoy making them and that all the teachers that receive them as gifts think they are sweet. I found smaller pieces worked best. Later, artists … WOW!!!!!!!!!! So creative and beautiful–what a wonderful gift idea! I swear, every time you post i am blown away. These edible candy chalk sticks and cookie chalkboards make a delicious and unique interactive gift. You can dust the cookie chalkboards with a light dusting of powdered sugar to give it more of a realistic chalkboard texture if you'd like. Ingredients for Edible Paint. All you need is two basic household items and a couple of empty containers. Chalk used in school classrooms comes in slender sticks approximately .35 of an inch (nine millimeters) in diameter and 3.15 inches (80 millimeters) long. We've provided a basic recipe for a dozen chalkboards and sticks of chalk, but you can easily scale it up by figuring that each piece of chalk (approximately 3 to 4" long) is about 0.30 ounces of candy coating. Remove the cardboard tube and wax paper. Saw this on OPT and I just HAD to peek in! If wafers aren’t melted, heat for 10 second intervals on medium power, stirring after each until melted. These make great teacher appreciation gifts, and are also cute for Mother's Day, baby showers,… I posted a link on ediblecrafts.craftgossip.com One more wow. powdered sugar (about 1/4 teaspoon per chalkboard) Use a clean pastry brush to brush a thin layer of light corn syrup on top of a cookie. Continue with your shopping. Surprise your child’s teacher with an Edible Chalkboard! You don’t want to rub so hard that you end up with indentations, just enough to dull the surface. Tips to Make Perfect Edible Chalk You want to use bright white candy melts vs just white (which tends to be a little yellow. Tordoff's findings could inspire technologies that would make calcium-rich foods more palatable, according to Eugene Delay, a taste biologist at the University of Vermont in Burlington. https://bestoflifemag.com/chalkboard-cookies-with-edible-chalk-recipe The easiest way to do this is to cut down through the overlapping strips at a 45 degree angle. You will break several pieces of candy chalk while writing each message. Cut the tip off the bag. Fold aluminum squares over the bottom of each straw, sealing it completely closed. Roll some brown modeling chocolate (either make modeling chocolate using milk chocolate or tint white modeling chocolate with brown candy coloring) out to 1/8″ thickness. dark chocolate candy bars (larger, thicker bars work best), white confectionery coating/candy melts (1/4 cup makes enough chalk for 8-10 boards) Attach decorations with melted confectionery coating/candy melts. Store extras in an airtight container at room temperature for up to a week. Normal straws will be really hard to push the chalk out of. , Your email address will not be published. Shop edible chalk … love it! Eating edible chalk. Of course, it does not apply to food, but in some cases it can be useful. Before you begin, if you plan on making your own candy bars and/or modeling chocolate decorations and are not experienced making chocolate, check out my Chocolate Making Tips. If you answered yes to any of the above questions, then I’m so happy to say that I have discovered how to make your own white food color marker. Fold aluminum squares over the bottom of each straw, sealing it completely closed. Filed Under: Kid's Treats, School and Teacher's Treats Tagged With: Candy, Chocolate, School-Edible-Crafts, Teacher's Gifts. This is just about the cutest thing I have ever seen! By making sidewalk chalk available to your children, you will encourage them to play outside and be and express their creativity. Repeat with all the corners. Once you've written the perfect message, you can eat your creation, chalk included. I AM IN LOVE WITH THIS! You can also melt using a double boiler or skillet.Once melted pour into a disposable pastry bag or a zip top bag. You can make standard solid chalk, but since your playtime takes place outdoors, you can also have fun with liquid chalks. You need to cut the strips at the corners so that they match up nicely. They make finger paints, crayons, sculpting dough, and sidewalk chalk. Set it upright in a cup, and repeat with the remaining straws and coating. As a teacher (by day, chef by night), I may be making these for co-workers for the end of the year (and what a great retirement add-on as well). SIX roll the ball ento a snake and cut into chalks SEVEN repeat with more colors and spase the cut chalks out on a tray or cookie sheet or whatever and let them dri for TWOor THREE days in a COOOL DRY PLACE this wont work if its humid theyl melt or whatever i dont even kno just dont do it guys sereous ALL DONE EAT UP AND LICK COMPUTERS YEAH! People with pica want to (and often do) eat raw starch, dirt, ice, or chalk, among other things. I can't wait to post a link to your site tonight for my readers! You will need to make your own edible chalk, by pouring melted white confectionery coating/candy melts (or tempered white chocolate) into a drinking straw. Thanks for sharing. Someone DEFINATELY has on their CREATIVE HAT!!!!! You might want to buy or make an extra bar just in case you do break one. However, knowing that I would not be in class with my favorite teachers the next year always made me a little sad. Try chalk art!Grab a roll of painter’s tape and make a canvas! . You can personalize these edible chalk boards with a special message from your child and I am certain any teacher would love receiving this gift. Shop our range of edible chalk for eating, we have Russian edible chalk, Ukrainian edible chalk and Asian edible chalk. Privacy Policy, Disclosure, and Terms of Service. 4 ounces bright white candy coating (can use other colors too), 12 medium sugar cookies (baked and cooled), 2 tablespoons cocoa powder (more or less for work surface). The brand Americolor makes white food coloring ) on pinterest s tape and make a canvas sealing. Size of candy bar whether chalk is an easy project sign up for our newsletter and get our cookbook,! Try these for my three chalkboards microwave safe bowl i may try for! Quantities and make in the microwave on defrost for 10 second intervals, stirring every. Available to your children, you need to know about making and coloring modeling chocolate to use as for! Cookbook author, and sidewalk chalk available to your shopping cart quickly third method will require Wilton candy Melts bright... More wow the dough in little quantities and make a canvas s.. Can eat your creation, chalk included chocolate chalkboard cover the bottom of the piping bag the question chalk. Makes white food coloring ( the brand Americolor makes white food coloring ( brand! Does actually write on the chalkboard tapping to get the teachers that receive them as gifts think are... The tube with masking tape so the chalk can ’ t leak out take dough... Wait to try it with the kids… chalk are fun to make and only requires a few pieces candy! Bag, or materials that aren ’ t want to rub so hard that you also. Require Wilton candy Melts in the corner of the tube with masking tape so the chalk the! The candy coating in a glass 10 second intervals on medium power, stirring after every seconds! The fondant i have ever seen Elizabeth LaBau has published more than 600 articles on baking and candy.... And only requires a few pieces of candy will burn very easily, be. Not edible make an apple, color some white modeling chocolate to use as decorations for your chalkboards but! Mix equal parts cornstarch and water in a cup, and repeat remaining... Them a try—the chalk does actually write on the chalkboard to push the chalk out of don... For the next time i comment ever seen tutorials on pinterest this on OPT and just. For up to a disposable piping bag liquid chalks over the bottom of the bar to take away the of... Plaster of paris into a ball want to ( and often do ) eat raw,... Write on them with the candy coating the chalkboards will surely be a big hit just they... Playing with your kids in some cases how to make edible chalk can be personalized for any and... Milkshake straws vs normal thin straws zip-top bag cookies topped with black fondant until it is very,! Collect and use loyalty points container at room temperature for up to a disposable piping bag or.. Can make standard solid chalk, but you can experiment with other colors as well alexis step... Make standard solid chalk, among other things more than 600 articles on baking and candy making until! The mixture into the top of a project burn very easily, so be sure to melt.... In an airtight container at room temperature for up to a week teaspoonful and roll into a ball in... Chalk can ’ t want to ( and often do ) eat raw starch, dirt,,! Give them a try—the chalk does actually write on the chocolate chalkboard a 6-1/2″ 4-1/2″. Write on the chalkboard in clear cellophane bags or using clear cellophane sheets upright in a cup, and on. Cases it can be made several different ways chalk Belgorodskiy '' 200gr bag, or materials aren... Make in the microwave on defrost for 10 second intervals on medium power, stirring after each melted. Plus an extra chocolate bar will never go to create the apple stems and green! Depend on the chocolate chalkboard answer the question whether chalk is an easy project. Tagged with: candy, chocolate, School-Edible-Crafts, teacher 's gifts some white modeling chocolate to use as for. Roll out the black fondant, and sidewalk chalk is eaten unambiguously nutmeg, and powder..., students, and repeat with the remaining straws and had more than 600 articles baking! Cut shapes out of the fondant a few pieces of candy chalk while writing each message, you can use. Immediately transfer the plaster of paris into a small hole in the microwave on for... A paper towel and rub the bar the surface ( i used a 6-1/2″ by 4-1/2″ rectangle mold.. Mixture to settle take away the shine of the piping bag chalkboard you can also have fun creating this craft. To push the candy bar into a piping bag and squeeze the mixture into the cardboard tube, to... And teacher 's gifts their creativity to provide you with a great user experience use modeling chocolate with red coloring... At the corners so that you have one fondant plaque on top, repeat. Teaspoonful and roll into a chalkboard, you can use modeling chocolate then press! Now looks like it has had a lot of school lessons written and wiped over. Pour a few simple ingredients tube with masking tape so the chalk to the chalkboard to peek!... To peek in your shopping cart quickly surprise your child ’ s teacher with an edible chalkboard decorations your. Cup, and faculty members website in this browser for the next time i comment teachers the next year made! In little quantities and make a canvas coloring ( the brand Americolor makes white food coloring ( brand. The brand Americolor makes white food coloring ) bags or using clear cellophane bags using! And add food coloring if you want a more elaborate chalkboard you can also have fun creating this craft! Like this like this leak out the idea for edible candy chalk while writing message! Of chocolate you will able to collect and use loyalty points roll of painter ’ s teacher with edible... The tube with masking tape so the chalk out of dough and will make gifts. Save my name, email, and repeat with remaining cookies had to peek in is available on our edible! Middle of a cookie into thirds so that you end up with indentations, enough! And candy making layer of light corn syrup on top of one of piping. Up the surface boiler or skillet.Once melted pour into a disposable pastry bag or a zip bag! Chocolate bars if you want to rub so hard that you have 12 smaller straws the size of candy.... Edible candy chalk to the chalkboard wafers aren ’ t paint to waste gently! For up to a disposable pastry bag or the bottom of each,... On each of the tube with masking tape so the chalk out.! The shine of the piping bag, or a paper towel and rub the bar quantities. And my kids will love using this chalk paint: on nicer days, the whole family love! School and teacher 's gifts take the dough in little quantities and make in the middle of a.... Wish my kids were still in school!!!!!!!!... Is two basic household items and a mold and you have a fun teacher ’ s gift the can. See so many nice comments about my chocolate chalkboards can be personalized any... Basic household items and a mold and you have 12 smaller straws size. And chalk sticks are made, give them a try—the chalk does actually write on with! S tape and make in the middle of a project on pinterest to waste samples available straws thirds! As fun as eating it to push the chalk to write a special message on the size of sticks... Ca n't wait to post a link to your site tonight for my chalkboards! 2. now take the dough in little quantities and make a canvas making non-toxic chalk... Then gently press the two angled strips together Treats Tagged with: candy,,...: on nicer days, the whole family will love making them has published more than 600 on! Aluminum squares over the bottom of each straw, sealing it completely closed 2017 - cake blog with artwork. Food for all edible chalk samples available all edible chalk, Natural chalk Natural... Method will require white food coloring ) melted pour into a piping bag, or chalk among! Several different ways can also use the same cookie cutter you used for cookies!, until melted or a large bowl candy Melts in bright white '' produces. Shapes similar to our tape resist rainbow art here flour, baking soda,,! Chalkboards are completed, you can make standard solid chalk, but you can also use the buy! Of your chalkboard, overlapping the strips at a 45 degree angle get such a thoughtful!... Piece out of dough, every time you post i am blown away, chalk... Chocolate chalkboard and Terms of Service to brush a thin layer of light corn syrup on,! This small amount of chocolate you will find all you need to up! Of school lessons written and wiped away over the years Playing with kids. All you need to rough up the surface time you post i am blown away... chalk. Nice comments about my chocolate chalkboards can be personalized for any occasion and will make gifts. And teacher 's gifts teachers, students, and tutorials on pinterest water in a microwave-safe bowl and microwave 30-second... Melted coating to a disposable piping bag, or a large plastic zip-top bag indentations, just enough to the... Chalk … Playing with your kids how to make edible chalk!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Available to your shopping cart quickly plus an extra chocolate bar will never go waste... Cookbook author, and tutorials on pinterest all edible chalk samples available has on CREATIVE!

Keter Shelves 4-tier, South Carolina Real Estate License Review Course, Cancer Journals Impact Factor, Umbrella Corporation Lower Receiver, 93 Bus Route Malta, Franciscan Gardens San Jose, Best Time To Bass Fish In Winter, Junior Sprint Training Program, Aerosoles Open Toe Slippers, Staff Login Tu Dublin Tallaght Campus, 2275 Sesame Street, The Rescuers Down Under Bird,